fbpx
Home
About Us
ABOUT US
Firm History & Expertise
City Legal is a multi award winning law firm specialising in UK Immigration Law, Wills & Estate Planning, Global Citizenship as well as providing Business, Education and HR Consultancy to both individual and corporate clients around the world.
Our Team
Meet the experts behind our success.
Accreditations & Awards
Check our credibility and reliability.
Reviews & Testimonials
View our client feedback from all sources.
Careers
Join our multi award-winning team.
Services
SERVICES
Knowledge Hub
KNOWLEDGE HUB
Resources
Quick and Easy access for relevant sources.
Videos
See informative videos on legal areas we cover.
Infographics
See visual presentation of key information.
E-Books
Digital information on different practice areas.
Webinars
View engaging online events & presentations.
Insights
Get more Insights on our firm and services.
News
Learn more on recent events and latest updates.
Podcasts
Listen to our audio version of blog anywhere.
Success Stories
Get a more understanding of our past experience.
View All
Contact Us
CONTACT US
Call Us
Speak with our award-winning team on 0330 058 3929 to learn more. Available Monday - Friday 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM
Request a Call Back
Choose a convenient time and we will get in touch to discuss your enquiry. Available Monday – Friday 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM
Chat with Us
Our expert legal team is available to answer your questions. Available Monday – Friday 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM
Email Us
Please send us an email to enquiries@citylegalservices.co.uk and we will be in touch to discuss your legal matter.
22 Peterborough Road, Harrow, London, HA1 2BQ
Client Area
CLIENT AREA
Track your Matter
City Legal offers our clients a state-of-the-art client portal to track your matter in real time and communicate with your case worker directly.
Manage Appointments
Already Booked a Consultation? Login to your Appointments Dashboard and manage your bookings or chat with your adviser prior to the meeting.
Document Management
Our clients can securely view, share and comment on documents online at any time via our dedicated document management portal linked to your matter.
Pay Legal Fees
We offer an online payment facility to our clients for the payment of Legal Fees or Client Invoices online by credit or debit card at no additional cost.
Download App   
Book an Appointment

Supreme Court says EU Citizens can be detained and deported

The Supreme Court in R (Nouazli) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2016] UKSC 16 makes it clear that EEA nationals can be deported by virtue of the Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2006, reg 19(3)(b) “if the Secretary of State has decided that the person’s removal is justified on grounds of public policy, public security or health . . . ”

However, the issue in the case was not the power to deport EEA nationals, but the power to detain them prior to possible deportation, as afforded to the UK by virtue of reg 24(1) of the 2006 Regulations.

The case concerned an Algerian national (the appellant) who entered the United Kingdom in 1996 and was refused asylum. He married a French national in 1997. He was granted a residence permit, and had acquired a right of permanent residence by February 2003. He had two children with his wife but they were estranged by July 2004 and she returned to France in late 2005. By the end of January 2012, the Appellant had acquired 28 criminal convictions for 48 offences, including one 23-month sentence. The Home Secretary unsuccessfully attempted to deport him for that reason in January 2007. But he continued to offend, and was sentenced to 20 weeks’ imprisonment for an offence of theft on 25 January 2012.

On 3 April 2012, just as the appellant was due to be released from custody for that offence, the Secretary of State served him with notice of her intention to make a deportation order against him under the Immigration (European Economic Area) Regulations 2006, on grounds that he would pose “a genuine, present and sufficiently serious threat to the interests of public policy” if he remained. He was detained from 3 April 2012 to 6 September 2012 (on bail from 6 June)pending a decision being made on whether to deport him. He was served with a fresh Notice to that effect on 7 September 2012, and was again detained from 7 September 2012 until 2 January 2013. The appellant contended that his detention pending removal was unlawful, and sought judicial review. He argued that his detention contravened article 27(1) of the Citizens Directive (2004/38/EC) and that reg 24(1) was incompatible with European law and unlawful because it discriminated against him on the basis of nationality without lawful justification contrary to Article 18 TFEU (there being no equivalent provision for pre-decision detention in relation to family members of British nationals or non-EEA nationals). The Upper Tribunal and the Court of Appeal dismissed his claim and appeal respectively. He appealed to the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court unanimously dismissed the appeal on all grounds. Lord Clarke gave the lead judgment.

In considering whether reg 24(1) of the 2006 Regulations discriminates against EEA nationals, Lord Clarke referred to Edward and Lane on European Union Law(2013), where, Professor Sir David Edward QC, observed: “Discrimination against third country nationals is not prohibited. It is presumed, and indeed expected, that they will be treated differently.”

In a short concurring judgment, Lord Carnwath states:

"The appellant has an appalling record of thefts and other crimes (described by the tribunal as mainly ‘petty opportunistic thefts’ not involving violence) extending over a decade before the events in question. They had resulted in jail terms amounting cumulatively to at least five years. It is not surprising that the Secretary of State’s patience ran out in early 2012 and that she set in motion steps for his removal from this country."

Disclaimer: No material or information provided on this website should be construed as legal advice. Readers should always seek appropriate professional advice to resolve their Legal Matters.
About the Author
Editorial Team

  Editorial Team

The editorial team is a group of team members at City Legal, focusing on the same area of law, contributing together to publish articles on our website and social media platforms.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram